The Brass Tax of Politics

Why “Prevailing Wage” Theory is Not the Answer


The recent ruling in finding NYC’s prevailing wage unconstitutional was the correct decision. Bloomberg understands the fundamental economic premise regarding paying a wage what the market dictates the worker is worth. Those that support the prevailing wage policies do not. It is both unfortunate and dangerous, because implementing a prevailing wage has two effects: 1) it devastates the very people its proponents think they are helping and 2) it erodes NYC’s economy by creating more barriers for businesses.

When a government takes taxpayer money, it takes it as a fiduciary; that is, it implies a relationship — legal, ethical, and economical — between “trustee” (government) and beneficiary (taxpayer).Therefore, the government has a moral, if not legal, obligation not to spend more money or pay anything more than the market demands.

The very act of paying $10 for something that costs $8, under the notion of “prevailing wage”, would put any other private businessman in trouble. Prevailing wage theory is not the government acting out of the kindness of heart, like its proponents would have you think. It raises the cost of goods to all constituents, increases the cost of living, and slows down the local economy.

The judge, although he ruled correctly, did so reluctantly — seemingly only under the technicality that the “law contravened state law”. He described how, “this court believes that the prevailing wage law could benefit the people of New York and does not see wisdom in the mayor’s zeal for the possibility of welcoming to New York City a business that would pay its building service employees less than the prevailing wage”. Bloomberg, however, hit the nail on the head when he countered that “legislation like this makes it harder for companies to invest in New York City.”

Here’s what the prevailing wage campaigners fail to discuss or flat out don’t understand from fundamental economics. The extra money being paid in a prevailing wage only benefits people that you can see. You do not see the hidden costs that add up to the employer, which create a net loss to the economy (deadhead costs). When you pay $10 for $8 worth of labor, it is identical to imposing a tax from an accounting point-of-view. What you see is the extra $2 going into the employee’s pocket. What you don’t see is the effects of the price increase on the business owner or the economy — how he absorbs the cost, offsets the cost, changes or slows production, cuts back hours or product, and so forth. That is the unspoken deadhead cost, a loss which has a ripple effect on the rest of the economy.

Prevailing wage is a scourge that must be stopped in its entirety, or else it will continue to grow. It doesn’t matter that one judge in open court halted the process. The people pushing for its policy must come to understand the basic economic premise — that when you artificially raise the price of something, you get less of it. Ergo, if you artificially raise the price of wages, you get less of that too — because many companies cannot afford the additional costs (or they would have to pass on the higher costs, but at the higher price there would be fewer buyers).

Artificial wage prices impede a business’ ability to grow and invest. There are many arguments against a “prevailing wage”, chief among them the burden on businesses — which are already struggling. The failure to understand the true effect of artificial wage control on the economy-at-large is frustrating. Such faulty logic is representative of the current trend to focus on feel-good rules rather than economic well-being for all. At least Mayor Bloomberg, who has been a successful businessman, (despite all his other faults) was willing to fight against measures like a “prevailing wage” that would keep NYC’s economy both depressed and sluggish.

Comments

  1. It is worst than a “scourge” and there are no words for it! It provides gratification to employees artificially and fills their pockets for trivial work that requires minor qualifications (GED) yet pays at a rate that even people with a Master’s Degree can not make. It sends a message to the Public School System…”you don’t have to study and earn a degree you just weasel your way through passing with low grades and getting into a prevailing wage job were your pay increases overtime (guaranteed). The City loves you and gives you lots and lots of money”.

    How can politicians say they want to improve education and yet send another message at the same time? “Out of the goodness of our hearts, you will receive prevailing wage and most every year in July it will increase…don’t worry your employer (the poor SOB) will pay for it. He’s the “bad guy”. You are the “good guy” and we are “your guardian angel.” GOOD LUCK EDUCATING OUR KIDS!!!! It will NEVER happen as long as there is an easy way out. Prevailing Wage destroys and is ridiculous in a Capitalist Based Economy. The theory is along the same line as COMMUNISM…yet we fought a Cold War against Communism and scold Communist Countries. What’s the difference when the principle between Prevailing Wages and Communism is the same? The government sets the wage scale…that’s Communistic? Against our Constitution. Minimum wage is fair to protect employees from abuse by employers. Prevailing Wage is wrong!

    The effect of prevailing wage is enough to make people paying it to throw up. There are many companies which refuse to perform prevailing wage work…the numbers are increasing. Quality in workmanship of prevailing wage jobs is decreasing. Time to completion in prevailing wage jobs is also extending. The Net effect is great reduction is productivity of the City. The City ends up loosing so much and if the Leprosy of Prevailing Wage is not halted it will continue to eat away at the fabric of this great City.

    Prevailing Wage is devastating. It deprives education and improvement through competitiveness. Why kill yourself? You are getting prevailing wage and the law protects you. “Go dust and clean and get prevailing wage to do it”. Why care about your performance? You are getting prevailing wage. Why study and educate yourself? You are getting prevailing wage. Why work hard? You are getting prevailing wage. Why pursue higher degree? You are getting prevailing wage.

  2. That is very interesting, You are an excessively professional blogger.
    I’ve joined your feed and look forward to looking for extra of your magnificent post.
    Also, I have shared your website in my social networks

  3. Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written
    article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and come back to learn more of
    your useful info. Thank you for the post. I will certainly return.

  4. Add your HTML code here...

    Hi! I understand this is kind of off-topic but
    I needed to ask. Does operating a well-established blog such as yours require a large
    amount of work? I’m completely new to operating a blog but I
    do write in my journal everyday. I’d like to start a blog
    so I can easily share my own experience and views
    online. Please let me know if you have any recommendations or tips for brand
    new aspiring bloggers. Thankyou!

  5. Spot on with this write-up, I honestly believe this website
    needs a great deal more attention. I’ll probably be back again to read
    more, thanks for the information!

  6. Very gokod site you have here butt I was wanting tto knlw if you knew of any message boards thwt cover the same topics
    talked about in this article? I’dreally like to be a part of
    group were I can get feed-back from other knowledgeable people that
    share the same interest. If youu have any recommendations,
    please let me know. Many thanks!

Trackbacks

  1. […] jack up costs. Prevailing wage is an economic compensation theory that requires municipalities to pay more-than-market wages. The end result of paying prevailing wages means that Detroit will get less with their our money. […]

  2. […] jack up costs. Prevailing wage is an economic compensation theory that requires municipalities to pay more-than-market wages. The end result of paying prevailing wages means that Detroit will get less with their our money. […]

Speak Your Mind

*